Glass Discussion & Research. No ID requests here please. > Murano & Italy Glass

Is this a Murano Knockoff?

<< < (3/3)

Frank:

--- Quote from: KevH ---How are we poor collectors supposed to know what we are buying? :(
--- End quote ---

TRY HERE  :twisted:

Ivo:
i am sure that the Weinfurtner Glashütte makes its own glass - however, this is a village full of souvenir shops riding along on the name using a retail label. Same goes for Murano - unless it says "made in" you cannot be 100% sure it was "made in" Murano - and even then - there is a village named Murano in Venezuela where they make simiolar style glass and use "made in Murano" labels.
Also reminds one of the village named Solingen in Japan....

Paul ADK:

--- Quote from: "Ivo" --- unless it says "made in" you cannot be 100% sure it was "made in" Murano - and even then - there is a village named Murano in Venezuela where they make similar style glass and use "made in Murano" labels.
Also reminds one of the village named Solingen in Japan....
--- End quote ---


Shades of USA!  I don't remember the whole story, but years ago, when the Japanese named a town "USA", (Made in USA) in a blatant attempt to deceive buyers, the United States was able to force them to cease and desist.  One would think that with all the trade agreements these days, Murano could protect it's trademark better.

Connie:

--- Quote ---Shades of USA! I don't remember the whole story, but years ago, when the Japanese named a town "USA", (Made in USA) in a blatant attempt to deceive buyers, the United States was able to force them to cease and desist. One would think that with all the trade agreements these days, Murano could protect it's trademark better.
--- End quote ---

In the US, the McKinley Tariff Act of 1890 established (among other things) that all goods imported into the US must be marked with the country of origin.  Then in 1914 (I think) the tariff act was amended to all goods must be marked "Made in XXX".

So in the case of the Japanese town named USA, the goods imported into the US would still need to be marked Made in JAPAN.

If you look at the label on the Murano piece posted here by KevH, you will see that it is marked "Made in Murano ITALY" to comply with the US trade laws.

Going back to the Japanese town, the goods could have been marked "Made in USA JAPAN" but I can see how the US would have banned those goods because it would cause confusion to the American consumer and was also an attempt to misrepresent manufacturing origin of the good. (BTW - interesting story which I had not heard before and cannot confirm.)

Of course none of this applies if the item was not made for the US import market  :)

Navigation

[0] Message Index

[*] Previous page

Go to full version