Confusing indeed ; )
I think mainly the reason I don't like the Clichy link is the setting and overall feel of the weight,
plus the roses - the roses seem a little different from Clichy roses.
The Christies weight seems to have some unwanted bubbles, is that common in older Clichy?
I've uploaded some pics of an old Clichy that's in the family below for comparison.
The roses are quite different, in the one below there are two roses, one regular green/pink/white with yellow center canes
and one pink/white with yellow centre canes.Clichy 1Clichy 2