The first, large one is a more orangey colour than the other, which is slightly redder (if that makes sense
) . But as to the handles, I thought they only came on jugs, but there is no spout, so I can only think that it is part of the decoration, hence the comment.
The bases look the same, with a slight dimple in the middle, and both are cased, and of the same quality glass.
BTW, they are off the flea market not a shop,which round here is a minor miracle as most "fings" are "Whitefriars, me duck, really expensive", which means, "I've heard the name, know they made glass,seen similar on TV, and can charge the earth for tat"