Alison, were you able to ID your candlesticks? I happened across a candlestick book that talked about this mold shape with four makers, Baccarat 'Swirl', Fostoria 'Colony', McKee 'Ray', and Kemple 'Twist' or 'Swirl'.
The Kemple has three nub footings added. Not what you have but is what I have here finally identified.
So if you haven't positively identified already yours then one not yet discussed earlier in the thread is McKee 'Ray'. McKee certainly did some early vaseline glass and they did sticks in that pattern but I don't know if they did those sticks in vaseline.