Sorry for the delay but wanted to get a good pic of all together. What differences did I note.
1. All the Carlo Moretti have ground rims, the red does not.
2. The red has a bit of shine to it, Carlo Moretti no shine at all.
3. The bases, while no pontil is evident on any of them, the red one seems to be flatter.
So in conclusion I will say that the red is not Carlo Moretti and India seems a sure bet. Thanks Ivo, Terry