Is the concensus right?
Should you have bought it? If you are only buying for re-sale, then the concensus is probably wrong.
2,3,4, concensus is probably right, however, the assumption that the public don't appreciate quality, only names, is the surest way of alienating the sellers from the public.
One question, do you personally like it? If so, consider that it only takes one other person who likes it, connoisseur or not, to potentially leave you in pocket. If you don't like it, few people will.
For me, it remains a very nice piece of work........