Glass Identification - Post here for all ID requests > Glass Paperweights

Ysart flower previously doubted is back on e-bay

<< < (4/7) > >>

KevinH:
I have moderated this thread to remove speculative and general comments about the possible maker(s) of the fake py weights. Such comments do not belong in this thread and in any event it is unwise to open discussions on that subject in a public message board without absolute certainty of facts.

pooleandpaperweights:
Going by past fake PY weights isn't it worth about 200 - 250 anyway?  I would of thought there was a small profit in in anyway, so I just don't see why she doesn't list it as a fake?

bigbri:
hi kev.
its very odd to say the least that on a thread about a fake py paperweight that the site doesnt want mention of the fact that those who are to blame are those that made them not the poor buyers and dealers who dont know the difference and who dont deserved to be slated by those who do know the difference and who mostly know the culprits.

chopin-liszt:
The whole point is that the stuff mentioned comes under Scottish law - this means documentary evidence is required before any speculations can be discussed.
This does not exist.

mjr:

--- Quote from: bigbri on December 12, 2012, 10:20:34 AM ---hi kev.
its very odd to say the least that on a thread about a fake py paperweight that the site doesnt want mention of the fact that those who are to blame are those that made them not the poor buyers and dealers who dont know the difference and who dont deserved to be slated by those who do know the difference and who mostly know the culprits.

--- End quote ---
Many people have ideas about who is responsible, and rumours circulate.  However without proof, then any comment on here is speculative and potentially libellous.   And whilst many buyers and dealers may have acquired such weights thinking they were genuine, the main topic of this thread is the current seller who, if they did not know previously, certainly now know the history of this weight and despite having it pointed out to them, continue to persevere with their erroneous description.   

Navigation

[0] Message Index

[#] Next page

[*] Previous page

Go to full version