Bernard it was not me who asked anything. It was in response to another who stated it was Sowerby on another site two years ago. Actually its on the URL already posted & if you scroll down (which I failed to do the first time) you will see the discussion that followed & a "Glen" agreed it was not Sowerby. Now if it was Glen Thistlewood (and I have no idea either way) I am certain if she knew the "who" behind the piece (carnival or not) she would have said so...if & I say if it was Glen Thistlewood.