Topic: Stuart Peacock vase

[essi]

Thanks for the prompt M. Have only just seen your post. I had a quick look on google images for Webb examples most of them are described as Stuart.

Will go through the previous posting tomorrow.

Thanks

[chch62]

So what is the difference between this Stuart peacock vase and the Whitefriars one by William Powell? They both look the same to me! Are either of them signed?

[flying free]

Hi and welcome to the board

To which vases are you referring please?
Please include photographs uploaded to the board so that a comparison can be made.

The only ones I found online were two sold, one in 2003 where the advertisement said  William Powell Whitefriars.  And another from 2015 (?) - links below.  I think that is very unlikely.  I suspect they are Stuart:
https://www.the-saleroom.com/en-gb/auction-catalogues/byrnes-fine-art-auctioneers/catalogue-id-1655609/lot-469641

https://www.liveauctioneers.com/news/columns-and-international/miscellaneana/miscellaneana-powell-sons-whitefriars-glass/

thanks
m

[MicksterPix]

I'm pleased to say that with a little expert help from  Richard @ Redhouse Glass Crafts, The Ruskin Centre. Stourbridge, my little vase which I'm now sure is STUART and Not Powell, should be back with me by Mid November.It's in a queue of glass items waiting to be 'cleaned' in a tumbler machine at this workshop. It takes 4 days of continuous tumbling with his mix of  cleaning powders.

[chch62]

Hi Flying Free
Thanks for your response - those are exactly the ones I was looking at - one says Powell, the other Stuart, yet they look the same. How do I tell them apart?

[flying free]

On the links I gave they both say William Powell Whitefriars.

I believe they are both Stuart.
I'm sorry I have no time at the moment to dig out catalogue or pattern references. 
So that is just my opinion.  Of course I am open to correction if someone has Whitefriars pattern references to disprove that they are Stuart though.

m

[chch62]

Hi
I have looked through Whitefriars pattern books online for this vase and found nothing, but of course I have not seen every design they made. I am curious how people have attributed it to Whitefriars.