I think the cylinder is an unusual, possibly early beast - I've not seen another the same. The smudgey yellow streaks are rather odd.
But there are tiny spatters on the blue stripes on the pin dish.
I've got a short egg-shaped vase with the much more basic Mdina-style blue with the yellow vertical streak and blobs, which I believe to be Phoenician too. Mdina did taller, almost-full-egg ones, Phoenician did eggs-with-their-tops-lopped-off shaped ones. It's not splodged, though. I don't have a pic to hand... will get one!