Random thoughts, Alistair.

Applied rims are notriously difficult to do.
Orange-coloured enamels are one of the most awkward and unpredictable enamels to work with.
Caithness does/did not produce large chargers with heavy, thick bases on a regular, "production" basis.
Large chargers tended to be specially designed things of limited editions, of which only the perfect specimens would be marked and numbered.
The seconds still got sold, as with the paperweights, they're just not marked. I've been lucky enough to pick up a couple of lovely big chargers, unmarked myslef. One has a big lump hanging down from the base surface on one side. I honestly can't find the flaw in the other.

Your charger/bowl has the added complication of the maker trying not to move the bubbles in the body while applying that heavy rim!
