Many thanks for your input, Chris!
I've been digging through Replacements today (you're right, it's a nightmare

) and I think I found the one on the right. Looks like it's Galway Leah, but I was actually hoping to find the other one as it's of a better quality. I just thought someone would recognize its very flared shape with a cut lump stem, but probably not this time...
Thank you for your help!