four more designs - from 1872 - 73.
one ……………… Reg. 269194 dated 23.12.1872 - Percival Vickers, Mchstr.
This goblet, together with the next item (tumbler Reg. 269694 also from Percival Vickers), show an identical moulded design feature of massive pillars topped by a deep mitred band encircling the piece, and both have a strong similarity of design to Regs. from Ker, Webb - Nos. 230596 and 236002 - showing in the last page or two, in this thread. A similar design of pillars and mitred band is also seen in the Downs Reg. 237893, a couple of pages back.
In view of Neil's link to the litigation episode between Ker, Webb and P.V., it's not difficult to see how tensions between these manufacturers arose - their separate Regs. for these 'pillared' designs could well be seen as too close for comfort perhaps to be simple coincidence, and plagiarism was obviously on someone's mind.
Unfortunately, it seems history hasn't provided us with the particular Reg. Nos. that gave rise to the 1871 dispute (though possibly Neil may have that information) - and since Downs wasn't a manufacturer, then might we infer that one of the two manufacturers in legal dispute, also made the Downs piece?
two ………………. Reg. 269694 dated 15.01.1873 - Percival Vickers, Mchstr.
Tumbler with pillars and mitred band. I'd overlooked the fact that Apsley Pellatt was selling heavily pillared decanters c. 1865, so always possible this design feature was enjoying some revival at the time these goblets and tumblers were made - pillars occur on decanters in the C18, and then again in the 1930s.
Reg .............. Reg. 274962 dated 08.08.1873 - John Derbyshire, Mchstr.
On this date J.D. Registered three new designs - 274961-63. It's only 62 and 63 that concern us here, since 274961 was a 'Design for Sugar, Cream and Service in what the factory drawing describes as 'THE PINE APPLE PATTERN' - and attractive it is too.
274962 is described as a 'Design for goblet and Service' - and shows a heavily moulded pattern with appearance of an oval looped design (see below) - people here will hopefully know what others shapes, if any, were produced with this moulded design. Have a vague feeling we've had a rummer on the Board in recent days with a very similar pattern, but memory could be failing me.
four ............. Reg. 274963 dated 08.08.1873 - John Derbyshire, Mchstr.
This is the other J.D. Registration from the 8th August group of three new designs, and again the factory drawing describes this as 'Goblet and Service in Glass', so the suggestion is that other shapes were produced with this design - sorry I don't immediately recall what they may be - am sure Fred or Neil will remind us.
If others have more information of interest to add, would be great, thanks:-)