Glass Message Board
Glass Identification - Post here for all ID requests => Glass Trinket Sets => Topic started by: NevB on June 20, 2020, 10:35:25 AM
-
There is a butter dish No. 18610 on P.3 of Marcus Newhall's Hermanova Pre 1958 CD. It is oblong rather than round but has the same finial and lid design to the pots of Mystery #145. Coming back to a previous post the tray shown in #145 doesn't match the other parts but does match the pots and ring holder in Mystery #47. Could it be there was a "mix and match" system at the time.
-
Hi NevB, the pots to Mystery Trinket Set #145 do have a comparable starburst in their base to the tray. Although a rounded shape starburst and not elongated per the tray, I still find they appear to be a match.
https://www.glasstrinketsets.com/Gallery/thumbnails.php?album=150
For several years I have noticed the asymmetric stepped finial of the Stolzle Hermanova Hut Butter Dish #18610 in Marcus Newhall's CD, matches the finials of Mystery Trinket Set #145. I have also seen photos of a Jam Pot and Honey Dish with the same finial and the honey has the same starburst in the base as the #145 trinket pots.
Hopefully it's okay to attach the image #18610.
-
Hello again Jayne, if you look in the Glass section I've posted a Hermanova lidded dish of the same pattern. I'm sure it's a match to Mystery 145 which I hope can now be attributed to Hermanova.
-
hello again Jayne, I meant to add that the tray in Mystery 145 has the same central pattern but the rim is actually a zig zag pattern and not a curved/scalloped? one. Although not obvious the pots in Mystery 47 also have the zig zag rim like the ring holder.
-
Hello again Jayne, if you look in the Glass section I've posted a Hermanova lidded dish of the same pattern. I'm sure it's a match to Mystery 145 which I hope can now be attributed to Hermanova.
Hi NevB, yes I've found the thread, here is the link,
https://www.glassmessages.com/index.php/topic,69715.0.html
Your lidded dish is certainly a match to the finial and starburst in the base of Mystery Trinket Set #145, also butter dishes were originally round to match the butter pat shape and later changed to rectangles as butter started to be manufactured in the rectangle shape, so both your dish and the #18610 image above could be butter dishes.
hello again Jayne, I meant to add that the tray in Mystery 145 has the same central pattern but the rim is actually a zig zag pattern and not a curved/scalloped? one. Although not obvious the pots in Mystery 47 also have the zig zag rim like the ring holder.
I'm not quite sure what you are suggesting here, trays from Mystery Trinket Sets #145 and #47 both have the same shaped edge, they are the exact same size and shape overall, I just went to double check on my own pieces, the only difference is the base pattern. The pots and ring holders differ in each set as you say. If you mean both sets are likely by the same maker I'd be inclined to agree.
Also there is a honey dish here Stolzle Pattern #18750 which I believe matches Mystery Trinket Set #47
https://www.glassmessages.com/index.php/topic,48082.0.html
-
Hello Jayne, what I was trying to say was the tray with Mystery #145 doesn't match the set and perhaps there should be another pattern of tray to go with it, one with scalloped edges not zig zag.
-
I think it would actually be better to refer to the rim as wave/wavy shaped rather than scalloped.
-
Hello Jayne, what I was trying to say was the tray with Mystery #145 doesn't match the set and perhaps there should be another pattern of tray to go with it, one with scalloped edges not zig zag.
Hi NevB, I'm still not following your thinking, the "zig zag" tray of Mystery Trinket Set #145 looks like a good match to me, in fact I think it it looks "wavy" but maybe I'm missing something?
Further, I have now added a thread on why I believe Mystery Trinket Set #47 shows photos of 2 differing sets.
https://www.glassmessages.com/index.php/topic,69725.0.html
-
Here's a close up, side on photo of a tray and one of the pots. The tray's rim design is made up of straight lines to form a zig zag pattern the same as the pots and ring holder of #47, the pot has a curved, wave pattern like the pots in #145.
-
Forgot to add the photo. :P
-
I don't have an example to show and can't find a thread on the forum, but if you do a Google Image search of "Stolzle Cruet" you should see a cruet set including a mustard with a zig zag rim, and a matching tray with 3 indentations for the salt pepper and mustard pot set, I have seen this cruet set in 3 colourways.
-
Yes Jayne, the mustard pot is, I'm sure, part of the same design suite as Mystery #47, the rest doesn't look like anything else in the before 1958 catalogue.
-
Hello NevB,
I've taken a look through my files and can confirm photos of at least 12 sets in Amber, Blue, Green and Pink with the footed pots with stepped asymmetric finial, footed ring holder and the central starburst tray with zig zag rim, and all with the same candlesticks, so again I believe Mystery 145 is a match.
It's possible another tray was available as were some taller variant sticks and other colours such as turquoise, but I have yet to see it.
-
Hello Jayne, what I was trying to say was the tray with Mystery #145 doesn't match the set and perhaps there should be another pattern of tray to go with it, one with scalloped edges not zig zag.
Hi Nev, I can now confirm I have seen Mystery 145 pieces 3 times on Stolzle Hermanova Hut tray number 18390. 2 pink sets 1 blue. Both pink sets were with tall variant candlesticks the same as my turquoise pieces in the pics below. The blue tray was with a single Mystery 145 pot base.
I think the set may have been modernised or just altered/added to at some point.
GTS Mystery 145 link: https://www.glasstrinketsets.com/Gallery/thumbnails.php?album=150
-
Thanks Jayne.