Glass Message Board
Glass Identification - Post here for all ID requests => Glass => Topic started by: singingyamada on November 27, 2013, 09:33:17 AM
-
I picked up this vase and had no way to describe it but someone has said that it is Japanese Cloisonne, but that can mean ( I think) alot. What I have seen similar is very pricey so I dont think I have hit the jackpot. Never my luck. Its seems to have a metal interior with a dimple ? enamel a clear glass outer layer and a silver or crome top and bottom rim. Nothing in the way of a makers mark. I kow there are fakes alive out there but just a little clarification would help. Thanks
-
It's metal, not glass, as you were told elsewhere. You perhaps need a Japanese forum rather than a glass forum. Enamels might be glass - but they don't count here unless they are on glass
-
AS has been said, it's Japanese Cloisonne - enamelled metal. If it was by a top artist it would be signed. Difficult to date from the photos, but they're traditional form; made any time from late 19th Century to today.
I can't tell from the photos if the flowers and birds have simply been painted over the top of the green enamel, or if they are themselves enamelled. If the latter, then it's proper cloisonne.
If there's is any form of damage then the value drops like a stone, and they are easily damaged by bumps and dings and corrosion of the metal underneath the enamel.
-
This is a nice example of Japanese cloisonne in the Ginbari style. The Ginbari refers to the beaten metal under the transparent enamel (which is so thick one could be excused for believing a type of glass. The floral decor is also enamel in opaque colours held in place by fine silver wire. The base ring is sliver.
If you get typical chinese cloisonne the base ring and rim will be brass. There will be brass wires separating the enamels and lots of "curls" in larger areas.
Here are some photos showing the various types. First photo is chinese, next two are Ginbari and the last has the opaque yellow background.
Ross
-
Meant to look up http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Vitreous_enamel which shows enamel IS glass and as such is no different to slumped glass or even pate de verre.
Ross
-
We know enamel is glass but
they don't count here unless they are on glass
-
As Ross said Ginbari,still being made today I believe,have a few myself, ;D ;D
-
See attached Art-deco image from Google. The glass is on metal (same as cloisonne) otherwise there is no item. Yet we all know stained glass. Why have a prejudice against another form?
A second image from Google Images makes it hard to see he has used metal but it is undoubtedly glass.
Ross
-
It's not a case of prejudice - stained glass is mentioned only infrequently here. Glass trimmed or decorated with metal is, but its base is glass not metal. If we are going to be all inclusive we should include glazed ceramics. It's about not being all things to all men and ending up helping no-one. Cloisonne belongs in the cafe. It's good Lee has been helped but it's a glass forum.
PS if those are not your images, you should remove them and provide links to avoid breaching copyright.
-
thanks so much to those for your clarification for what I assumed to be glass over metal and therefore a glass question. Now that I fell scolded and embarrassed . I will leave it
-
I have neither tried to scold you or embarrass, rather to explain why it's not glass. I apologise if I've upset you
-
I felt embarrasses by your tone and that you talked over me . I cannot make it any clearer, however apology accepted. And thanks to Keith and Ross for saying in a civilised manner.