Glass Message Board
Glass Identification - Post here for all ID requests => Glass => Topic started by: brambles46 on November 01, 2006, 02:02:18 PM
-
hello Frank
Thank you and as you can see I am your latest member - my first reading suggests that some of your participants are a little immature - I recently sold a marble on e-bay for £3600.00 and another for £1970.00, a Clichy paperweight for just over £900 - check my completed listings - I am no m-----, nor have I lost my marbles. Are you jealous or frightened of success?? I left name calling many years ago and now enjoy intellectual debates and discussions - my initial reaction is that I will not find it on this site but like everything in life I am prepared to try.
Regards
Gordon
-
Gordon, welcome to the board, I hope that you may find it informative and useful.
Just to correct your misapprehension: the board is not Frank's but actually belongs to Dr Angela Bowey - the lady whose text and images you misappropriated in your listing. May I refer you to the Board Policy posting http://www.glassmessages.com/index.php/topic,6521.0.html.
-
Hi Gordon,
It is not my Message Board, although I help out. I think that the other discussion can be cleaned up now as you did the decent thing and removed the offending material. We cannot control what people say though we do impose limits within our guidelines.
The contents of the forum, The Glass Encyclopaedia and The Glass Museum are all copyright. But a simple request to use material is often received favourably as many of us are dedicated researchers and writers who like to receive full credit for their efforts, as well as determine what can or not be used elsewhere.
In any case welcome to the board, I am sure this incident is quickly forgotten and we will be glad to help you out if you need it.
-
I appologise Anne and Frank, i lost my temper, welcome Gordon. also my appologies to you Gordon
-
Welcome Gordon. We enjoy all forms of intellectual discussion and debate here, mainly focussed on glass, of course.
Many of us here are researchers, writers, designers and artists - and as such we tend to guard our intellectual property and copyrighted material very carefully.
Glen
-
Welcome Gordon. It'll be great to have a marble expert on board the GMB, how long have you been interested in them? Are you a collector yourself?
-
Welcome, Gordon! I guess you'd say I'm definitely counted among the more 'immature' members! :lol: There's all sorts here, and room for all on the whole, or so I've found :wink:
Paperweights are my real area of interest, and I do love Clichys, so I'd love to see some if you care to share! :D
-
Hello Gordon, I've responded to your email to me - but I'll repeat here - many thanks for altering your listing, I'm sure the owner will appreciate the swift action you've taken. Welcome to the board, it's a great place and, as you will know, fiercely loyal to it's members. Looking forward to your contributions to the board.
-
Gee, I hope this isn't the last post on the subject. Brambles46 was wrong to take Dr. Bowey's text and use it to sell an item on eBay.
Brambles46 did the good thing in removing the copyrighted material. The members of the GMB who inundated him with Email The Seller messages were right and proper to act.
-
Hello All
I didn't think this matter would create such a stir - I thank you all for your good wishes - I am retired from the legal profession and my partner and I now run an e-bay site selling for the antiques trade (only the antiques trade, no private sales) here in Northern Ireland – we get all sorts of interesting things to sell, not all glass related, however apart from the marbles and paperweights already mentioned, we offered for sale two Lalique vases this last week and obtained £880+ and £300+ for the seller (less commission of course) - we have received a collection of about 20 paperweights to sell which will be going on sale within the next few days when we have had time to research them – that’s about me at this moment and time – I hope to communicate with you all soon – Regards Gordon and Ida
-
Hello Gordon, and welcome to the board.
Thanks very much for doing the right thing and removing the offending material. I think we recognise that it was an honest mistake.
It would be acceptable to use any of the information, as long as the information was paraphrased, the source credited, and none of the photographs were used.
Glass researchers care very much about their copyright. Angela has put an enormous amount of time, effort and money into developing her Glass Museum, for very little return, and so naturally we flew in to support her when the copyright breach was noticed.
Good luck with the Jobling bowl, and we look forward to seeing you here.
(You might be interested to know that one of your pieces is classic Mdina from Malta)
Kind regards
Cathy.
-
(You might be interested to know that one of your pieces is classic Mdina from Malta)
Kind regards
Cathy.
Welcome to the board. People here are passionate about glass and you will find, perhaps despite your preconceptions, that they are very willing to give and help others. So despite a rocky start, Cathy's note above about your Mdina piece is a good example. Particularly if you are selling as an agent this could make all the difference between a good or excellent result!
Now that the dust has settled a little, I might add that most people are usually impressed by vendors who clearly research their subject, provided copyright is acknowledged, and now that you have altered your listing, I think a majority would agree that you are to be commended for taking the trouble to ensure a correct provenance. :D