Hi, thanks for the message. The 19423 item is actually oval whereas this is circular, and is also more of a dish than a flat plate. It is also different in respect that the square tops of the similar items in the catalogue are much chunkier, (I have examples of several of these items), and the feet are a different form. I thought it looked like a Hermanova piece but have not been able to track it down in that catalogue. Thank you for the suggestion though.