Topic: Maker of these round vaseline salt shakers?

[cubby01]

I just know I saw these online a week or two ago while looking for something else but now I can't find them.  Can someone help me out.  I don't think they are that uncommon.  I don't have a clue if the lids are original - the shiny ones don't fit very well, too tight.  The second from left is quite old though is a bit loose.

Can't tell from the pic but the one far left is opalescent.  The three right of it are all uranium glass.  At first I thought it was one of the inverted thumb print pieces but I don't think so.  Then another piece with similar pattern called this Fenton Coin Dot, but I have looked at Fenton's patterns but don't think it could be.  I've also searched on hobbs thinking one of them was Rubina Verde in color pattern. 

Thanks in advance.

[Sid]

Hello

I would put my money on these being Hobbs, Brockunier's Polka Dot aka Inverted Thumbprint.  The shape is similar to their 226 shakers.  Note that 226 refers to the shape not the pattern.  One caveat is that the peach blow and coral examples of this shape shown on page 81 of the Bredehoft Hobbs book look like they have two piece lids.  If you have this book, you might want to note that they are incorrectly captioned as No. 228 shape instead of 226.

Sid 

[cubby01]

Thanks Sid,
I saw this page a day or two ago that had a shaker listed as "Rubina Verde" which kinda had me thinking Hobbs Brockunier but I wasn't sure.   The page didn't seem to attribute a maker.  That page is here..http://www.thelampworks.com/salt_shaker.htm ..(3rd picture into the page).  Is that Hobbs Brockunier Polka Dot?  I'll have to dig through my books.  I have a variety but don't know if I have anything dedicated to Hobbs.
-Buck

[Sid]

Buck

Looking more closely at your photos it looks like your shakers have a raised ring just below the lid.  If so, they are not Hobbs' 226 shape.  Hobbs made all these colours but so did a few other companies.

Sid 

[cubby01]

Ah, I see that now.  Another clue anyway.  Thanks!