Topic: Is this a Kralik ?

[glass-shelf]

I suppose this vase could have been made by Kralik. Can anybody confirm or contradict ?
Am i right with the idea that it has been done round 1920 ?

Thanks in advance,
Tom

[keith]

Hello Tom,will look it up and get back to you,unless someone beats me to it

[scimiman]

Have a look on the base and look for a tiny J & Z interlinked as it looks like it might be Jan Zeeman.
Mike www.abfabglass.co.uk

[glass-shelf]

Have checked the base again, there is no mark visable, so very unlikely Jan Seemann, i conclude.

Tom

[obscurities]

Is the rim ground and polished?

Also, some pics in natural light may help, as the colors, at least in these pics do not look quite right for a Kralik piece....

Craig

[glass-shelf]

Thanks Craig !
Here comes more pictures that might help.
The colour is more into green, the pictures are little too yellow.

[Lustrousstone]

It reminds me of this http://www.glassmessages.com/index.php/topic,31034.0.html

[obscurities]

Although it bears a resemblance to a Kralik decor, I do not believe this is a Kralik piece. The piece does not seem quite right. Although I think it is older than the piece in the link, I am not sure who it is....  I would likely lean towards a more contemporary piece, even though the bottom appears to show some wear....

The Kralik pieces have a much more iridescent surface treatment, and the primary color of the body, combined with the color of
the blue are not quite right. Additionally, I could not find any examples of the decor with a line pattern such as this.....

I have attached a couple of variations of the Kralik decor for comparison.....

Craig

[glass-shelf]

Although it bears a resemblance to a Kralik decor, I do not believe this is a Kralik piece. The piece does not seem quite right. Although I think it is older than the piece in the link, I am not sure who it is....  I would likely lean towards a more contemporary piece, even though the bottom appears to show some wear....

The Kralik pieces have a much more iridescent surface treatment, and the primary color of the body, combined with the color of
the blue are not quite right. Additionally, I could not find any examples of the decor with a line pattern such as this.....

I have attached a couple of variations of the Kralik decor for comparison.....

Craig

Craig,
thanks a lot !
As i never owned a Kralik piece, i do not know how it looks like. How do the top rim look like and have Kralik pieses a polished pontil ? Probably you could send pictures of top rim and bottom of the first vase, this blue-yellow one ?! 
These chinese ones look diferent i think, somehow more new.
Tom

[scimiman]

Have a look  here
I am convinved its still a Jan Zeman piece that has not been signed.
Mike