agree, I think most people would do the same. Having looked at some VSL goblets with cased/cut to clear similar to Roy's piece, it's difficult to find any with this hobnail/cane cut decoration - though of course it might just be me not looking in the right direction. Flamboyant knops - cut notches on the arises - fan splits, aren't a problem, it seems just the actual cut pattern that appears perhaps uncommon for VSL. Might be the other side of the pond - could be the U.K. - or even somewhere else on the Continent. I think we're going to struggle with this one, but fingers crossed.