Hi, can you please start a new thread for the extra vase as it causes extra work for the mods to try and separate out the links if they are from different makers. I don't think they are from the same maker. I think the rim of the extra vase is probably fire polished isn't it? rather than cut and ground and unpolished which the other two appear to be?
It also has a signed mark on the base and someone may well recognise it. I would head it appropriate at least including 'signed cylinder vase' in your title , try and do a side on shot and also a rim shot as well. :sun:
m